diff --git a/allstarr/Services/Spotify/SpotifyTrackMatchingService.cs b/allstarr/Services/Spotify/SpotifyTrackMatchingService.cs
index 27f9e39..24ca90f 100644
--- a/allstarr/Services/Spotify/SpotifyTrackMatchingService.cs
+++ b/allstarr/Services/Spotify/SpotifyTrackMatchingService.cs
@@ -884,12 +884,19 @@ public class SpotifyTrackMatchingService : BackgroundService
                                     ExternalId = externalId
                                 };
                                 
-                                matchedTracks.Add(new MatchedTrack
+                                var matchedTrack = new MatchedTrack
                                 {
                                     Position = spotifyTrack.Position,
                                     SpotifyId = spotifyTrack.SpotifyId,
                                     MatchedSong = externalSong
-                                });
+                                };
+                                
+                                matchedTracks.Add(matchedTrack);
+                                
+                                // Convert external song to Jellyfin item format and add to finalItems
+                                var externalItem = responseBuilder.ConvertSongToJellyfinItem(externalSong);
+                                finalItems.Add(externalItem);
+                                externalUsedCount++;
                                 
                                 _logger.LogInformation("✓ Using manual external mapping for {Title}: {Provider} {ExternalId}", 
                                     spotifyTrack.Title, provider, externalId);